July 2008 issue. The art of conservation

tooltip tooltip tooltip tooltip
home arrow interact arrow personal essays arrow Muslim/Mormon
Muslim/Mormon PDF Print Email
Caught between heritage and faith.
By farnad darnell / Silver Spring, Maryland
Tuesday, 08 April 2008

Image
Farnad Darnell, October 2002, at the house of a friend. (Christine Taylor)
 

I remember sitting in Wisconsin while the coup in Iran was being broadcast on television in February 1979. Bearded clerics and their black-clad disciples had their fists and banners in the air, while they forced the Shah into exile and the country into a Muslim theocracy where politics and religion became married. I was just nine years old, but I remember thinking, “Don’t hurt my people.”

I was born in Iran, sometime in December 1969. Only days after my birth, I was left on the doorstep of a police station in Gorgan. The authorities took me to the capital, Tehran, and put me in a government-run orphanage that had been founded by Empress Farah Pahlavi, the wife of Shah Mohammed Reza Pahlavi.

Then one day in 1976, I was pulled out of school and driven back to the orphanage, where I met a short dark-haired woman wearing a rain coat and glasses. She spoke a strange language that made me giggle. Later she would tell me that I reminded her so much of her son David when he was that age, that she immediately knew I was the one she wanted. The Holy Spirit had guided her to me, she said. Indeed, she believed the Holy Spirit had led the family to Iran just so they could find me.

At the time, the family was living temporarily in the industrial seaport town of Bandar-e ’Abbas. She was teaching English to adult Iranians, while her husband was working for a British company that built ships for the Iranian navy.

So I was adopted — into a family of Mormons.

The family I joined was certainly American. For much of my childhood, my new father, mother, two older sisters, three older brothers, and I lived in a two-story Victorian house in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, a lazy, beautiful town of shipbuilders and tourists. I learned to play Tag and Kick the Can, helped mow the lawn, participated in Little League games, sailed, biked, and went to garage sales and barbeques.

When I got older, I played football, sometimes as a running back, but mostly in the “left-back” position — as in “left back on the bench.” I watched our 13-inch black-and-white television like any other American kid, but maybe with a bit more attention to events like the Iranian Revolution.

But even more than being an American, I was a Mormon. At eight years old, I was baptized into the church. At 12, I was ordained a deacon, which meant I could pass the bread and water for the sacrament to the congregation. At 14, I was ordained a teacher. At 16, I became a priest, which meant I could say the prayer on the bread and water. At 18, I was made an elder.

And then I went on my mission for which my parents had been saving up money in a piggy bank since my baptism. I remember receiving the letter from the Salt Lake City, Utah headquarters of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, informing me where I would be serving God.

I opened the letter, hands shaking and afraid to read the words, with thoughts of an exotic mission to some far-off place in South America or a French-speaking part of Africa. I had taken French and Spanish in high school and put those languages on my application.

Then I learned where I was going, the one place I would have never imagined: “You have been called to serve in the Nevada, Las Vegas Mission.” I spent two years in Sin City knocking door to door, baptizing and participating in the baptism of 24 adults and children.

With the religion came attitudes that seemed like bedrock principles. I learned that abortion is an abomination, divorce is a disgrace, and Democrats are just wrong about nearly everything.

After my mission I did what was, once again, expected of me: I got married.

Looking back at it now, I remember having doubts about my faith as young as 12, when I become a deacon. I felt like a fake at church, and I had an urge to be a rebel. But having been adopted, my fear of being rejected by my family was stronger than my need to question them or the church, so I did what I was supposed to.

But one event began to turn this upside down. My wife and I got a divorce. Under the Mormon faith, she was to write a letter to the church to obtain permission for our divorce and then send me a copy for my approval and signature. (Being the man, I didn’t have to write my own letter.)

It wasn’t until I started conducting research on Iranian Americans for my master’s thesis that I was struck by the parallels between the life of the Muslim I would have been in Iran and that of the Mormon I became in America.

Both religions were founded by men who suddenly had a vision of God — one god being “Allah,” the other being the “Heavenly Father.”

While both cultures revere women in their roles as mothers and emphasize the strong bonds of family, both are also male-dominated and oppressive to women on many levels.

Women in Orthodox Muslim culture have to wear a veil to cover their bodies; women in Mormon culture have to dress conservatively. Divorce is frowned upon by both cultures, and if divorce is necessary, the burden of proof is on the woman. Men are in positions of power in both religions — they are imams and clerics in Islam, and prophets and general authorities in Mormonism.

My study of these two religions led me to look at other religions. Then, one sunny afternoon in June 2002, I had a sudden moment of clarity while reading a passage in an English translation of the Quran that read just like one of the 10 commandments of the Bible. If the Quran and the Bible and the Book of Mormon and the Torah all have the same “moral guidelines,” why does each religion think it better than the others? What is the basis for centuries of religious wars, the clash of civilizations, the modern threats of terrorism, and religious-inspired nuclear annihilation?

I found myself feeling both disappointed and relieved. I was disappointed that it had taken me so long to understand what now seems self-evident to me, and relieved that I suddenly, after all these years, realized it was okay to question.

In looking at other religions and their political associations, I recognized the fears instilled in both religions. In Iran, to turn away from Islam is to deny Allah, for which punishment might equate to death. In Mormonism, to deny the “one and only true church” might lead to a punishment of loss of a social network and friends.

I often fight between my own belief of what should be and what I was taught: the hell of not following what I questioned about the church versus an underlying fear of going to “hell” when I had been taught the “truth.” I was fully inculcated with the fears, teachings, and beliefs of Mormonism, and it is difficult to deny that while a child can leave a church, the church may not leave the child.

To answer my own questions, I have looked elsewhere for a foundation of beliefs that do not resonate with such orthodox theocracies. I have found that my ultimate truth is the blending of all religions’ positive teachings and the forsaking of their fear tactics. In short, to teach love is my ultimate truth.

Trackback(0)
Comments (12)Add Comment
muslim/mormon
written by Seeker, June 01, 2008
Having a fair understanding of both systems of thought, mormons and muslims, the essential question I finding unanswered is "how can man, who is a mix of good thoughts, actions, and deeds, ever hope to be pure in heart and see God?" As good as I try to be I always fall short. Unlike the muslim or the mormon, I know that I need a savior because my good works would never be enough.
I hope the author continues on his journey and finds joy, truth, and peace as he walks this life.
Seeker
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Stefanie, May 10, 2008
Superb aricle! I believe most people following a religion are trying to be moral, and that most religious teachings probably advise us well. However, I, too, have concerns about the 'brainwashing' aspect, the blind faith, the fact that quotes from religious passages can be manipulated to justify and give apparently irrefutable support to anything, and the fear instilled in children.

I completely agree that we should take and embrace the positives from all religions, while rejecting the negatives. Such a process would require thought, which would be an added benefit.

Stefanie
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Marc Latham, April 15, 2008
I think that New Age Paganism and Buddhism provide the best values and hope for humanity to live in peace and preserve the planet.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Woman, April 09, 2008
I, too, was raised Mormon and have, independently, observed much the same things and reached much the same conclusion as has Dr. Darnell. While the Mormon religion contains and promotes too much good to warrant a complete write-off.... it contains the same flaws as do all religions: the mark of humanity and social pressure that is inevitable in all cultures and all religions. The inconsistencies and weaknesses I found in the Mormon religion can all be explained by predictable human, social behavior. The shunning and ostracism that definitely occurs towards members who "stray" or "disbelieve" is not based in the religion's doctrines, but in the judgmental and critical nature of all humans. In fact, that shunning and ostracism is directly contradicted by the religion's teachings to "judge not, lest ye be judged"...to "love one another"...to "turn the other cheek"...and to condemn the method of ensuring "good" that was supposedly proposed by Satan of eliminating one's ability to make one's own decisions (the very proposal that Mormons believe makes Satan evil).

I agree with Dr. Darnell that there are remarkable similarities between the Mormom and Muslim religions with respect to oppression of women. Again, however, I believe this stems from cultural norms found across civilizations and not necessarily from specific religious texts or religious doctrine (contrary to the interpretations of religious scholars). The oppression of women stems from the innately human/social desire for "stronger" groups to oppress and control those who are weaker. Men's physical strength has forever allowed them to dominate and control the women who have always been dependent on them for survival. And, as Dr. Darnell correctly observes, the cycle is hard to break when the threat associated with attempting to break that "social" cycle is both social rejection and isolation and eternal damnation. One cannot prosper without the support of a social group and, as is true of much religions, that social group usually consists almost exclusively (or at least primarily) of members of one's own religious group, who harbor the very ideologies that one finds unacceptable.

If there is a God, I find it hard to believe that he or she cares how long my skirt is, whether my top is sleeveless, or whether my jeans are too tight. Likewise, I find it hard to believe that he or she expects anyone to submit themselves to the control of another -- or to be prohibited from (or punished for) divorcing one whose actions and/or beliefs do not comport with one's own. In fact, the types of controlling marriage (and prohibited divorce) encouraged by these religious groups directly impedes the objective of Mormonism (and many other religions) to be accountable for one's decisions and to strive toward becoming a more perfect person, as reflected by the decisions we make independently -- while acting with the resources and ability to live independepently and truly make own's one voluntary decisions (which is not possible when one is subject to the repercussions of another who holds the pursestrings and upon whom one's social acceptability depends). A complete dependence on another person over whom you have no control (the effects of whose decisions are unavoidable by you if you are completely dependent on that person) is contrary to the heart of Mormonism's philosophies.

For me, like Dr. Darnell, the best "answer" to the dilemmas presented by the inconsistencies between religious groups' practices/behaviors and my own insights (which agree with the heart of Mormonism's (and many other religions') teachings) has been to appreciate the positive things I learned while growing up in this religious culture (which are many), to learn to distinguish between principles and human/social groups' imperfect application of those principles, and to pass on to my own children and others only those aspects that I know in my heart to be right -- like loving others, helping others, and overlooking others' imperfections.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Thoughtful Words!
written by Bill, April 07, 2008
I joined the LDS Church while a senior in high school. I had been a Baptist and had grown tired of what seemed to me to be "instant salvation." I was looking for a faith that was more about a continuing journey of insight and self-improvement. Mormonism was too good to be true.

I served a mission, married in the temple, had children and served in the Church. But over time, I found persistent gaps between Gospel explanations and a sinking sense that what I was being told wasn't entirely true. It might make for a great metaphor - a tradition through which one could build a community - but there were claims that didn't add up.

I like the epiphany you've had. There is truth all around. The real issues of life are not to be found in the supremacy of one sect over another. They're in the hard work of building families, relationships and in finding fulfillment in life.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by yabajobu, April 07, 2008
I find your camparisons without any sense of proportion. Equating the fear of death with the fear of losing friends hardly seems like the same thing. Likewise "conservative" dress (which is advised for both men AND women in the LDS culture) hardly seems on par with the absolute covering required by Islam. These kinds of comparisons would see no difference between a High School football game and the SuperBowl.

Additionally, Mr. Darnell never answers the question he poses: why have there been religious disagreements over the years? He evades answering it, content to leave it unanswered to justify his own religious beliefs. Mr. Darnell's question gets at the heart of religion, which is whether there is a correct way that God or Allah would have us live. It is a shame that Mr. Darnell has not the courage to answer that question.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Persis, April 07, 2008
More than this being about the righteousness of any religion or message, it's fascinating to me on the human level. I thought you articulated the importance of understanding how much a person wants to belong--to feel loved and cared for--and that sometimes that comes at a price to one's own sense of truth. I am so proud of you for questioning and for finding your own path!
barikala!
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Love is A Verb
written by Anonymous, April 07, 2008
If we do not seek we do not find.
If we do not seek in faith we do not find it as testimony.

"love is a verb" it is a wonderfull book

Love without service is dead just
like faith without works is dead.

"If we make love a verb, then peace becomes a noun, and zion a reality" (from the book).
I truly believe this, and know that love is the greatest of all commandments. I am a mormon, and i know that this is what the church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day saints encourages.

You are all truly wonderful, indeed i am pleased to know that people do receive answers to their prayers, and the windows of heaven are open. This is indeen a royal generation.

smile =)


report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
The Sum of Existence . . .
written by Jeff Brooks, April 06, 2008
is truth. There are truths to be found from many sources.

I absolutely love your article. I was raised in the church and remain an active member. I find many of the claims of church rather weak and some truth all together lacking. The blindness of faith in the church is staggering. There is, however, too much good to chunk the whole thing out the window, at least for me. There is also too much good in other places not to include them in my life.

Again, excellent writing. I hear you!

JB
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Sam, April 06, 2008
Mr. Darnell, in my experience I have found that you can form and promote almost any opinion and find some evidence (or personal interpretation) to back up your opinion. I have traveled the world and had personal experiences with Muslims, Mormons and members of many different faiths and backgrounds. The vast majority of people in these faiths are good people who are trying to be better. They follow the teachings of their faiths which, by in large, teach love for one another. As far as theology, my understanding of Muslim theology is limited (although I probably have more understanding than most who are not Muslim) so I do not feel I can speak to whether or not the majority of their theology teaches about love (although I'm assuming it does). I CAN, however, speak to Mormon theology. The mantra of Mormonism is to help bad men become good and good men become better. I personally have been taught to value other's opinions and to love others as Jesus taught. While you have the right to your opinion, I cannot allow your opinion of Mormonism or Islam de-value the experience of millions of others. I too have found that many religious have the same "moral guidelines." This realization has actually helped me gain greater appreciation for the faiths of those with whom I work and live. I love my Mormon faith. And I love the faith of my Baptist, Catholic, Evangelical, and Muslim friends. And even though some of them speak of damnation and fire for non-believers, I am more overwhelmed by their love and concern for others.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Is the glass half full or half empty?
written by Fleeting Thoughts, April 06, 2008
Mr. Darnell,

I enjoyed reading your thoughts and comments about being born in Iran a Muslim nation and then being raised as a Mormon. I too see some similarities between Muslims and Mormons; however, I hadn’t considered comparing their punishments. Modern management theory indicates people will not be well motivated by fears. I hope you will not let your fears run your life.

For me, those that truly love their religion do not obey because of fear, rather they are truly motivated internally to love, serve, and help those around them. I find it wonderful that you have discovered “to teach love is [your] ultimate truth”. I wonder though, if there is no god what is the purpose of love and why are you motivated to teach love as an ultimate truth if there is no One that can deliver on the promise of peace?

Love is the only reality and it is not a mere sentiment. It is the ultimate truth that lies at the heart of creation. - Rabindranath Tagore
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
...
written by Don Layton, April 06, 2008
My experience with Mormonism has been quite different than the author's. My experience has been one of eternal families being bound together through priesthood power, of the loving sacrifice of Jesus Christ who atoned for my sins, my frailites, my weaknesses, my infirmities. It has been one that has helped me to teach correct principles to my children, who are now becoming wonderful, responsible adults and young men. It has been in teaching me to serve others without thought of "what do I get out of it". My experience with Mormonism has been exactly what I would expect my Savior and my Lord would have me learn and do and be.

So, Mr. Darnell, while I appreciate your perspective and certainly your right to follow your own conscience, I would want you to consider that there are millions of us who have a vastly different experience than you have had. I hope and pray that your happiness is genuine and lasting.

report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy


Recommend this article
Reddit!Del.icio.us!Google!Facebook!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Yahoo!

Last Updated ( Tuesday, 08 April 2008 )
 
next >
in_other_words
Freedom is fragile and must be protected. To sacrifice it, even as a temporary measure, is to betray it. —Germaine Greer, writer, broadcaster, academic, and feminist
 
about · contact · privacy policy · donate · site map · rss rss
advertise · republishing & syndication · submissions · join staff · bugs & errors
affiliate_links
  Powells.com affiliate link  Netflix, Inc.
© 2008 INTHEFRAY Magazine
In The Fray, Inc., is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization (EIN/tax ID number: 04-352-0135).
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.